PDA

View Full Version : If they only reveal 2 careers...


Selendor
08-15-2007, 11:51 AM
So the pessimist in me is thinking that they'll do what the did for Empire/Chaos, and only reveal the first 2 Careers, and leave us hanging on the others. Assuming they do this (I hope not), which 2 would you like to see?

Melee DPS and Tank gets my vote. Those seem to be the most contested, obviously moreso in the Melee DPS slot. But they'll probably reveal the Sorcerer/ess, as if it's something groundbreaking that we never expected. :P

roadkizzle
08-15-2007, 12:01 PM
Yes, what I noticed in the Empire/Chaos pairing, they only released the names of the shoe-in classes first, and nobody was surprised, and waited till the very end to tell us the spots that nobody could guess... And I hate them for it too.

From what the dev's have been saying, this is an all or none, but I am still worried that they will do it like they did with empire and chaos.

That being said, I hope that they do tank and melee dps. With those two, we can easily figure out what the other two are going to be probably.

But, if they only release two it will be sorceress and witch elf :( ... I'm betting on it.

dynamo112
08-15-2007, 12:22 PM
I thought I heard somewhere that when they reveal the elf class's they were showing all. :confused: Anywho, I voted tank/melee DPS.

Gleipnir
08-15-2007, 12:24 PM
Tank/melee dps. Really cant wait to see if executioners are in! Or if i have to settle on corsairs or black guard.. or none of them at all :(

Plx no cold one knights

Gleipnir

AlienOverlord
08-15-2007, 01:07 PM
Well the Kotaku article does say 'The first of the details' on the Elf armies. I guess it's not likely we'll get everything dumped into our laps all at once.

Aside from the elves I hope that we'll get to see working versions of the KotBS, Witch Hunter, Marauder and Chosen in PvP Scenarios!

Bulwyf
08-15-2007, 01:12 PM
I really hope they reveall all four but if its just two then I want tank/melee DPS. I need to konw how much I need to bang my head in the wall or not. :p

Black Razor
08-15-2007, 01:18 PM
I'm certain they will reveal the Sorceress in whatever roll shes in first, as its pretty much an implied class. Beyond that I think it will either be ranged (if the Sorceress isn't the ranged, which only leaves one real option) .. or the melee DPS. I am willing to bet they are as in contention over the Tank as most of us are. Its pretty much the wild card slot right now for the Dark Elves, but who knows. Anyways my fairly apprehensive bet goes to melee DPS/Support as the first two.

Xurré
08-15-2007, 01:26 PM
I think I’ll join the choir and vote tank/melee dps.

Obviously I want to know melee dps more than anything, but also knowing the tank class should be enough to indicate whether Witches are in or not (because they so don’t make sense anywhere else).

Of course I do hope that they’ll just reveal all of them. And I’m curious where people get the idea that they’ll do so (or is it just wishful thinking?). From what I’ve heard (http://kotaku.com/gaming/gc07/warhammer-elves-invade-leipzig-289634.php) it’ll be “exclusive first details about High Elves and Dark Elves”, which doesn’t exactly fill me with hope that they’ll tell all eight classes.

There’s one problem with the question posed by this thread though... when they reveal class names, how do you know what roles they’ll be? For instance, if they say “Sorceress” how do you know whether it’ll be ranged or support (or something else)? I wasn’t around during the unveiling of the human careers... do they tend to just say the names or reveal a little bit more about them?


- Xurré

roadkizzle
08-15-2007, 01:40 PM
Well, how you tell which each class will fit together is by looking at all the classes.

Say, if they give us Sorcerer, Witch Elf, Executioner, and Corsair... I'm willing to bet that sorcerer would be ranged dps, witch elf dps/healer, executioner tank, and corsair melee dps.

If they say Black Guard, Shade, Witch Elf, Sorcerer, I'm going to say that Black Guard is tank, Shade is ranged dps, Witch Elf is melee dps, and Sorcerer is support.

If we have melee dps, then that will give us a very good idea of what most of the other classes are. And tank is just a wild card so would be nice to know.

Lorik
08-15-2007, 01:47 PM
Regardless, my head's still going to explode before I find out. :(

Xurré
08-15-2007, 02:13 PM
Say, if they give us Sorcerer, Witch Elf, Executioner, and Corsair... I'm willing to bet that sorcerer would be ranged dps, witch elf dps/healer, executioner tank, and corsair melee dps.
Hmm, in that case it would make more sense for Corsair to be ranged. :p

If we have melee dps, then that will give us a very good idea of what most of the other classes are. And tank is just a wild card so would be nice to know.
The problem is, how would you know that what they give us is the melee dps archetype?


Regardless, my head's still going to explode before I find out. :(
Mine already did. :???:


- Xurré

roadkizzle
08-15-2007, 02:20 PM
Xurre, possibly, but we would at least be much closer to figuring out the roles than we were before.

abr4
08-15-2007, 03:54 PM
What is it with those melee classes all the time? >_>

Spikenog
08-15-2007, 03:56 PM
Tank and Healer...with out these guys you have no group. Unless War is planning in breaking that mold...and if they are...then why are there tanks and healers?

Lexi
08-15-2007, 06:19 PM
I want to see the Dark Elf healer type, noooow. :(

Syr
08-15-2007, 06:46 PM
Ranged and support. I doubt I'll play the melee.

Jinsei
08-15-2007, 07:09 PM
I really want to hear what the DE tank is. I'm also vaguely interested about the melee dps.

Estebar
08-15-2007, 09:25 PM
Melee DPS/Healer.

Let's end these relentless discussions before I end up hanging myself with the dental-floss thong under my chainmail bikini...

Zoatibix
08-16-2007, 09:13 AM
Melee DPS...don't really care about the second class ;)

Although since we have waited so long it would be nice if they released the names/roles of all four now. That gives them plenty of time to string out the details between now and a couple of months before release.

zoa
08-16-2007, 12:27 PM
Melee DPS and Tank

Blaze
08-17-2007, 02:31 PM
I'm going to play whatever the tank class for DE is, because I want to be DE and I want to try PvP tanking. And I'm really curious about the melee dps slot even if I won't play one.

So tank and melee dps.

Eltair Shadowblade
08-17-2007, 02:56 PM
I'm going to play whatever the tank class for DE is, because I want to be DE and I want to try PvP tanking. And I'm really curious about the melee dps slot even if I won't play one.

So tank and melee dps.
same, tho im not 100% sure.
if the tank is black guard/cold one knight the chance ill be rolling a dark elf tank is very high

Blaze
08-17-2007, 03:53 PM
if the tank is black guard/cold one knight the chance ill be rolling a dark elf tank is very high

Unless they come up with some entirely new class I don't see what other options there are. Unless they come up with an entirely new class that mixes the two a bit. Call it Dread Guard or Dread Knight.

Either way they chance of seeing a high elf noble in heavy armor is very high. Tanks are often seen in a sort of leader role (see KotBS) aka nobes for Druchii. Black Guard are Stubborn and Hate everything in the TT and that could translate well into a durable tank class that never surrenders and takes no prisoners (in a proverbial sense, they do take some to use as slaves after all :P).

WastedTrojan
08-17-2007, 04:50 PM
Ranged dps/support

I usually play ranged dps and I can't think of anything plausible for a DE healer so im curious.

Thoden Firehammer
08-17-2007, 06:37 PM
I'm certain they will reveal the Sorceress in whatever roll shes in first, as its pretty much an implied class. Beyond that I think it will either be ranged (if the Sorceress isn't the ranged, which only leaves one real option) .. or the melee DPS. I am willing to bet they are as in contention over the Tank as most of us are. Its pretty much the wild card slot right now for the Dark Elves, but who knows. Anyways my fairly apprehensive bet goes to melee DPS/Support as the first two.

I don't want to have to eat my own foot for this later if i'm wrong, but i'll say it anyways.

We already know that Mythic is going with the natural lore and thay did go to GW for permission on using male Sorcerers even if they didn't Sorcerers would still be viable
With the lore due to the fact that it's common knowledge that Dark Elves view the law as "it's in illegal unless you get cought"

Aviator
08-19-2007, 10:30 AM
Ranged and Melee DPS. Ranged DPS because I like playing those type of classes, and I'd like to know all my options. Melee DPS because it'll finally end all the heated debates on this forum.

Estebar
08-19-2007, 12:17 PM
We already know that Mythic is going with the natural lore and thay did go to GW for permission on using male Sorcerers even if they didn't Sorcerers would still be viable
With the lore due to the fact that it's common knowledge that Dark Elves view the law as "it's in illegal unless you get cought" Yes Thoden, you've mentioned that same line in about five different threads, and misspelled "caught" in every single one of them. Take your beard out of your mouth, man!

They'll have to do a little better than that, I'm afraid. Fighting within Malekith's army, among his loyalists, the royal guard, executioners, wives and assassins, I don't think there's anywhere else in the world where you'd be more likely to get caught! Not to mention, there's rumour of tier 4 quests being given to you directly from your leader.

Assuming that male sorcerers are playable and not just included in-game as NPC's hiding in the shadows, they're gonna have to do a little lore-bending...

Gemini
08-20-2007, 10:23 AM
Melee DPS because it'll finally end all the heated debates on this forum.

Oh man, as much as I want that to be true, it won't be. It pretty much has died, I guess because of Leizpeg(or because every point has been made 200 times over by at least 40 diffrent people), but with the release if the new info, it will only bring more. More "OMG WTF MYTHIC?!" and "Why [class name here] should be the melee class", and "[class name here] sucks!"

Dasquigman
08-20-2007, 10:26 AM
alot of people put tank DPS but you guys already know of alot of them Order has Ironbreakers and Distruction has black orc, and chosen. how bout a change?

Gemini
08-20-2007, 10:35 AM
alot of people put tank DPS but you guys already know of alot of them Order has Ironbreakers and Distruction has black orc, and chosen. how bout a change?

Uh.... your point? We know all the classes for Empire, Dwarfs, Greenskins, and Chaos. All the melee dps, all the tank, all the ranged dps, all the support. All of it. This is about elves, of which we know nothing(though some people are so sure of themselves they think they know what one or more of the classes will be).

zenarion
08-20-2007, 10:53 AM
I want to know what the Tank and the Supporting caster/ranged DPS will be.
Have my fingers crossed for Manticore rider.

JayArgh
08-20-2007, 11:19 AM
i'd, personally, like to know about the tank and melee DPS. but as for what i think will be released... Support and ranged DPS...

it just seems that the most obvious choices for careers/classes are Sorceress (support) and Shade (ranged DPS). these, at least, would be the easiest to translate from teh tabletop game to an MMO.

(fingers crossed for Black Guard as tank)

zoa
08-22-2007, 12:27 PM
This thread was the cause of us only finding out 2 of the classes, thanks a lot! ;)

Xurré
08-22-2007, 01:09 PM
This thread was the cause of us only finding out 2 of the classes, thanks a lot! ;)
But at least the choice with the most votes was what we got: tank and melee dps. ;)


- Xurré

JayArgh
08-23-2007, 12:31 AM
This thread was the cause of us only finding out 2 of the classes, thanks a lot! ;)

zoa... you really thought they were going to give us EVERYTHING we wanted RIGHT AWAY. tsk tsk tsk...

kidding... kidding...

zoa
08-23-2007, 03:48 PM
zoa... you really thought they were going to give us EVERYTHING we wanted RIGHT AWAY. tsk tsk tsk...

kidding... kidding...

A man can dream can't he, for it is our birthright to reach for the stars, to... sorry :P