IRONBREAKER or BLACK GUARD? who wins

[xxxIRONxBREAKERxxx]

ok me and my frineds have ben debatin this 1 for ahwile now im wondriing wut u guys think abot it

my friedns say that the black guard can do lots of dmg and stuf but i dont think so i mean theere elfs for freaks sake how muc can elfs acutally do befor they get all tired n sutff theyer not the type 4 huge battles an d lots of killng to do

so i tihnk tht ironbreakers woud win no doubt theyre dwarfs!!! so much power and theyre called ironsbeakers how is a black guard gunna stop somthing who can breaks iron i dont think it coud happen itink ironbrakers woud win ever time becuz theyer the best class nad can defintelly do alot more dmg then elfs cna theyer was stronger and more damgage then any elfs could do

[HardXCoreIronBreaker]

Well, hell I had to come to these forums to defend my fellow Iron Breaker friends. doin be fooeld by my name, CAUSE WE WONT GET FOOLED AGAin..sorry THE WHO fan joke anywa.

Anyway I have thought about this too myself, and I just have to say the blackguard has wicked sick armor, and has strict set of rules to stand by. Hes defintly a worthy opponent of the ironbreakr, this would bea wicekd sick fight, and I cant wait to see what happens on the battleifeld. Honestl in a 1v1 I belive hte inrobreaker has the chance to take hte carrot cake on this one. The ironbreaker has alot of armor and some big beefy weapons.

Sorry blackguards you might lose this one, but your blakcguards pwn aevery other calss.

thats my 2 cents.

[Mutters]

Ironbreaker has an advantage b/c he is the best physical damage tank, though his damage is tied into grudge, which means you have to hit his friends for him to really ramp up. Black guard gains hate as he is damaged, so it'll depend on which career will ramp up to their burst damage first. IB is a soak tank, and BG is an avoidance tank.

IMHO, its an even battle, it'll go 50/50 every time. What it really depends on is healers and group dynamics for both of these classes.

Mutters

[Duty]

Browncoat has my guess.

Sorry, that was completely not constructive :(

[Jinsei]

In a 1v1 fight, Black Guard hands down. Hatred>Grudge when it comes to 1 on 1

In a more open world fight, who knows? We have very little info on the Black Guard, but seeing as how his opposition is a dawi, the edge goes to the BG yet again.

Silly dwarfs. You're only good for making our weapons and clothing our hides.

[Relentless]

Ironbreaker has an advantage b/c he is the best physical damage tank, though his damage is tied into grudge, which means you have to hit his friends for him to really ramp up. Black guard gains hate as he is damaged, so it'll depend on which career will ramp up to their burst damage first. IB is a soak tank, and BG is an avoidance tank.

IMHO, its an even battle, it'll go 50/50 every time. What it really depends on is healers and group dynamics for both of these classes.

Mutters

Since when is the BG an avoidance tank? I've heard that said about the swordsmaster, but not the BG. Just because he's an elf doesn't mean he's focused on avoidance. BG's are decked out in heavy plate for a reason, and it's not to play la de da avoidance dances.

And we'll wipe the floor with your short, hairy little hides. While you're busy muttering and worrying over keeping count of your grudges we'll just step on your beer stained beards and expose your short, fat necks for a nice easy start on chopping you up into three pieces.

[twinoceans]

you should have posted this thread in the dwarf forum. posting this thread here just get you slaughtered by dark elves fans.

[waffel]

ok me and my frineds have ben debatin this 1 for ahwile now im wondriing wut u guys think abot it

my friedns say that the black guard can do lots of dmg and stuf but i dont think so i mean theere elfs for freaks sake how muc can elfs acutally do befor they get all tired n sutff theyer not the type 4 huge battles an d lots of killng to do

so i tihnk tht ironbreakers woud win no doubt theyre dwarfs!!! so much power and theyre called ironsbeakers how is a black guard gunna stop somthing who can breaks iron i dont think it coud happen itink ironbrakers woud win ever time becuz theyer the best class nad can defintelly do alot more dmg then elfs cna theyer was stronger and more damgage then any elfs could do

I don't get it. You have an infinite amount of time to make a thread. Also, windows makes it almost impossible to mistype a word between Firefox's auto correct and Microsoft Word/Works auto-correct. So please, tell us, how you managed to incorrectly spell so many words? Did you do it on purpose?

[Dan gerous]

I think its a joke.

However, the iron breakers grudge mechanic will be useless 1 on 1. Therefor I think the black orc will have a slight upper hand.

[The Penguin Hunter]

I think its a joke.

However, the iron breakers grudge mechanic will be useless 1 on 1. Therefor I think the black orc will have a slight upper hand.


Actualy I remember it saying that the Ironbreaker gains grudge from people aslo hiting him OR his allies

[Azrayne2.0]

Bad troll is bad.

[twinoceans]

xxxIRONxBREAKERxxx (http://www.warhammeralliance.com/forums/member.php?u=19519), HardXCoreIronBreaker (http://www.warhammeralliance.com/forums/member.php?u=19523) , XxXIrOnPwnBrEaKeRxXx (http://www.warhammeralliance.com/forums/member.php?u=19526) are all the same person, i think. if i'm correct, then he's such a loser that he created 3 accounts just to compliment on himself. just read the thread "B33r Tank" and you know what i'm talking about:
http://www.warhammeralliance.com/forums/showthread.php?p=590669#post590669

[Krouv]

Mark Jacobs was absolutely right... as release gets nearer, the number of trolls will rise exponentially.

[twinoceans]

Mark Jacobs was absolutely right... as release gets nearer, the number of trolls will rise exponentially.
yeb, just for this month, i've seen the greatest amount of pointless threads like "man, warhammer screenshots look awsome." but still, the guy who made this thread is the biggest loser yet, for creating 3 accounts to compliment on himself. this guy got some serious problem.

to the X's guy:
get a job! get a girl friend! go to school! maybe those will cure your problem!

[Paragonn]

As much as i love my blackguard (and ill be playing 1 :p ) i think the IB would win :(

This is assuming the blackguard is using his signature halberd and the IB his shield. The IB would prolly just avoid most of the attacks from the BG. Ofc, we can only speculate, but i think it may go to the dwarf.

IF however (just to make me feel better) the BG were to use a shield as well, the BG would win without a doubt! :D

[HardXCoreIronBreaker]

We came here to get some heated debates going, and yo put some spark in the ironbreakers forums, before our thread was made there was 2 threads in there. We felt the Ironbreakers needed a little love and a little bit of representation.

To call us out like that only makes you look worse, we come here for the love of the game and get humiliated. Whats the point.

[Dan gerous]

We came here to get some heated debates going, and yo put some spark in the ironbreakers forums, before our thread was made there was 2 threads in there. We felt the Ironbreakers needed a little love and a little bit of representation.

To call us out like that only makes you look worse, we come here for the love of the game and get humiliated. Whats the point.

Like I said before. A joke. Was pretty obvious by the way you typed. Some people just don't applicate it is all.
I'd like to see these forums go off when we have some solid stats and abilities of the classes.

[Dante]

Please do not feed the trolls. (http://uplink.space.com/attachments/270850-DoNotFeedTroll.jpg)

[Faezroth]

Judging by the "beer tank" thread i am quite confident that iron loler will be banned along with all his accounts soon.

[Browncoat-WHA]

To the OP and co.,

It's nice to come by and start threads for discussion and spark some debate. However, we do try to stay away from what you are typically used to seeing on other forums. If you go through threads on here you will see what I am talking about. Sometimes it is best to lurk for a few days before posting a thread. Sadly a thread like this doesn't quite cut the mustard, especially when comments arouse some suspicion.

And to folks as a general thought - on internet forums, sometimes if it looks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it isn't always a duck. Basically, feel free to hit the report button on threads and posts, and then let us look into it. No need to necessarily post as well. Thanks guys and gals.

Gonna lock this up as it is way off the original topic.

*LOCKED with a hot pink paint can*